Near South Third Street, a pedestrian tunnel runs under Pleasant Street. Its north end is painted with an interurban electric streetcar, a Midland Railway train, streets lined with star bricks, the White River, plum trees and peonies. Its south walls carry two concrete reliefs, one of a peony and one of a cardinal. Drivers on Pleasant Street pass right over it, and from the road you can't see any of it.
This month that tunnel and the trail through it helped a road project win Noblesville a statewide placemaking award.
Accelerate Indiana Municipalities named Reimagine Pleasant Street a winner of its 2026 Placemaking Award at its Ideas Summit in French Lick on September 30, in the category for cities over 50,000. The City of Noblesville announced the award on October 6. Aim CEO Matt Greller explained the choice in the city's announcement: "It's exciting when the recipient of the Aim Community Placemaking Award is a community that turns infrastructure into identity."
The road part is familiar by now. The city's release describes a $125 million, 2.5-mile east-west corridor from SR 32 west of downtown to SR 37 on the east side. It has six roundabouts and three bridges, and it is expected to cut downtown traffic on SR 32 by about 20%. City leaders had been looking for that relief for more than four decades.
The rest of that same list is what the award was about: three pedestrian tunnels, an extension of the Midland Trace Trail, public art by Noblesville native Phoebe Davis, history murals by the Wilkinson Brothers, interpretive signs, and preserved star bricks. Most of it sits along the trail, so the way to see what won is on foot or by bike.
The first phase of the project ran 1.3 miles from River Road to 11th Street. It included a five-span, 600-foot bridge over the White River, the Midland Trace Trail extension with a tunnel under Pleasant Street, public art, and rest areas about local history. That phase opened in November 2024. The Indianapolis Business Journal placed the tunnel near South Third Street and said it serves people on both the Midland Trace and Riverwalk trails.
Corey and Casey Wilkinson of Wilkinson Brothers, Inc. painted the north end of the tunnel. According to the city's project announcement, the mural marks where three trails link up: Riverwalk, Midland Trace and Nickel Plate. Each image in it refers to a piece of Noblesville's history.
| In the mural | What it points to |
|---|---|
| Interurban electric streetcar | The city's historic interurban line |
| Star brick-lined streets | Noblesville's rare local paving brick |
| Train on the Midland Railway | The rail history behind the community's connections |
| The White River | The river the corridor crosses on its new bridge |
| Plum trees | The surrounding Plum Prairie neighborhood |
| Peonies | Indiana's state flower and today's celebrations |
The brothers explained the work in the same announcement: "For many years, we've played in its waters, ridden its trails and enjoyed its downtown – we hope this mural shows our appreciation and prompts some smiles from passersby." The Hamilton County Reporter covered the unveiling in June 2024.
Phoebe Davis-Dearth's two concrete reliefs face the mural from the south walls. One shows a peony and the other a cardinal, Indiana's state flower and state bird. The 2026 project nomination to the Indiana chapter of the American Public Works Association also credits her with a cast-in-place concrete mural on the Phase 1 trail. The peony shows up in both artists' work and again along the road. The city links it to the Indiana Peony Festival.
There is more art close by. IBJ reported that the pillars of the new White River bridge carry scenes of the river. In October 2024, the Reporter covered student-designed artwork placed on three wastewater tanks at the Noblesville Utilities facility along the corridor.
The plum trees in the mural point to the most important decision behind the corridor, and you can't see that decision from the road either.
Pleasant Street skirts the Plum Prairie Historic District. The APWA nomination describes it as a neighborhood settled first by Delaware Indians and later by Noblesville's working-class African American community. The city weighed several routes and chose one that kept the road out of the center of the district. That choice saved 10 historic homes from demolition.
The trail tells that story. The city worked with the Noblesville Preservation Alliance, local historians and the firm Weintraut & Associates on historic signs along the Midland Trace Trail.
The nomination pairs the signs with a respite area along the Midland Trace Trail, which makes it a natural place to stop and read. So the art and the signs tell the same story. The mural paints the plum trees, and the signs a short walk away explain whose neighborhood they stand for.
The tunnel art keeps coming back to connection, and the trail layout backs that up. Here is how the trail pieces line up along the corridor, from west to east:
The section with the most to see has been open the longest. The Phase 1 trail around the tunnel has been in use since November 2024, almost two years before the award. If you've only driven the corridor since the full road opened last December, the art has been there the whole time, under the road.
The place where the Midland Trace and Nickel Plate trails meet is getting more attention. On September 2, the city and Flaherty & Collins broke ground on The Granary, a mixed-use project planned for 223 apartments, 5,000 square feet of retail and about 300 parking spaces. It also includes a trailhead connecting the Midland Trace and Nickel Plate trails, and the city expects the project to be finished by the end of 2028. That trailhead is still a plan, so for now the tunnel near South Third Street is where the corridor's art and history are.
In 2024, before most of the corridor opened, Mayor Chris Jensen told IBJ, "We can make big decisions. We can make wise decisions for our city's future." The mural, the reliefs and the Plum Prairie signs are the parts of that decision you can see from the Midland Trace Trail.
I love watching Noblesville's newer places add to its sense of identity, and I'm always glad to talk through how a trail connection, a new project, or a stretch of history like Plum Prairie fits into the bigger picture of where you live or want to live. If the Pleasant Street corridor has you curious about what's changing nearby, I'm happy to share what I know. Reach out to Mya Williams anytime. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Experience personalized service, honest communication, and dedicated support from your first consultation through closing day. Partner with Mya Williams for expert guidance, local knowledge, and a client-first approach to every real estate transaction.